The Best and Worst MAC Cosmetics Products

Your shopping guide to this cult-fave makeup brand

Before you buy your next eyeshadow or makeup brush — check out these unbiased reader reviews. They reveal that of all (and there are thousands) of the MAC products available, the brushes top every makeup-lovers list. But not all MAC products are perfect — so be sure to steer clear of the ones on our readers’ do-not-buy lists.

See products

The Worst: No. 4: MAC Green Gel Cleanser, $19.50

TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 6.0*

What you said: “It doesn’t [have a] rich lather and it doesn’t leave my skin feeling fresh. I guess it’s ok for…”

No. 3: MAC Prep + Prime Eye, $16

TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 5.7*

What you said: “I figured since MAC has such great eyeshadows, they’d obviously have a great primer for them… WRONG!…”

The Best: No. 15: MAC Eye Shadow, $14.50

TotalBeauty.com average member rating: 9.4*

What you said: “THE best eyeshadow I have ever used. I will never switch to another brand when it comes to…”

Want to see the rest of the list? Click here!